How to Identify and Avoid Predatory Journals in India

India contributes approximately 35% of all papers published in predatory journals globally. This is not because Indian scholars are careless — it is because the publication pressure on PhD scholars and faculty is intense, the legitimate publishing process is slow and uncertain, and predatory journals have become extremely sophisticated at mimicking legitimate ones.

A predatory journal publication is not a neutral outcome. It is actively harmful: your university will not accept it for thesis submission, it earns zero API points, it can be flagged during thesis examination, and in some cases it has led to disciplinary proceedings. For a scholar who spent months believing a publication was in progress, discovering that the journal was predatory is one of the most damaging setbacks possible.

This article tells you exactly how to identify predatory journals before you submit — and what to do if you have already published in one.

What Makes a Journal Predatory

The term “predatory journal” refers to publications that exploit the academic pressure to publish — accepting papers with little or no peer review, in exchange for publication fees, while falsely presenting themselves as legitimate scholarly outlets.

The key characteristics are:

False or fraudulent indexing claims. The most common predatory tactic in India is claiming SCOPUS, Web of Science, or UGC CARE indexing without actually being listed in these databases. The journal’s website, email solicitations, and even published papers may assert indexing that does not exist.

Guaranteed or rapid acceptance. Legitimate peer review takes months. A journal that promises publication within days or weeks, or that guarantees acceptance subject to a fee, is not conducting genuine peer review.

Aggressive unsolicited email solicitation. If a journal emails you inviting submission — especially if the email is generic, addressed to “Dear Researcher,” or references a paper you published elsewhere — treat it as a red flag. Legitimate journals do not cold-solicit authors.

Fake or unverifiable editorial boards. Many predatory journals list eminent scholars on their editorial boards without those scholars’ knowledge or permission. Check whether the listed editors actually exist and are affiliated with real institutions.

Unusually high or untransparent publication fees. Legitimate journals either charge no APC, or clearly disclose their APC on the author guidelines page before submission. A journal that reveals its fee only after acceptance is not operating ethically.

Poor website quality. Grammatical errors, copied content, vague aims and scope, and plagiarised information from other journals or Wikipedia are common in predatory journal websites. These are visible, easy-to-spot signs.

Why Indian Humanities Scholars Are Particularly Vulnerable

The Thesis Guide has worked with scholars across MP, UP, Rajasthan, and other states who have inadvertently published in predatory journals. The pattern is consistent:

The scholar is in Year 3 or Year 4 of a four-year PhD. The thesis deadline is close. They need a publication before they can submit. They have tried one or two legitimate journals and either been rejected or are waiting for responses. Then they receive an email from a journal promising rapid review and publication within 30 days. The journal claims UGC CARE or SCOPUS indexing. Exhausted and under pressure, they submit.

This sequence — deadline pressure, prior rejections, unsolicited email — is the exact environment predatory journals exploit. Knowing this in advance is the best protection.

The Five-Minute Verification Process

Before submitting to any journal, complete this verification. It takes five minutes and can save months.

Step 1 — Check SCOPUS. Go to scopus.com/sources. Search by the journal’s name or ISSN. If it is listed with active status, it is SCOPUS-indexed. If it is not there, it is not SCOPUS-indexed — full stop.

Step 2 — Check UGC CARE. Go to ugccare.unipune.ac.in. Register and search by journal name or ISSN. Confirm the journal is listed and is not on the discontinued list.

Step 3 — Check Beall’s List. Beall’s List (maintained at beallslist.net) is a reference list of known or suspected predatory publishers and journals. If the journal or its publisher appears on Beall’s List, do not submit.

Step 4 — Google the journal name + “predatory” or “fake”. Scholars who have been deceived by predatory journals frequently post warnings online. A quick search often surfaces specific reports about journals operating as scams.

Step 5 — Read a published paper from the journal. Download a recent paper from the journal’s website. If the English is poor, the arguments are weak, the citations are sparse, or the paper appears to have received no real editorial attention, the peer review is not genuine.

If a journal passes all five checks, it is safe to submit.

Journals That Claim to Be Listed But Are Not

One specific pattern deserves special attention: journals that appear on third-party “indexing” websites that are not SCOPUS or UGC CARE but look similar. Sites with names like “Global Impact Factor,” “Index Copernicus,” and dozens of others are not credible academic indexing services — they are often themselves monetised by predatory publishers.

The only indexing that matters for Indian PhD purposes is:

• SCOPUS (verified at scopus.com/sources)
• Web of Science (verified at webofscience.com)
• UGC CARE (verified at ugccare.unipune.ac.in)

Any other “indexing” is not meaningful for your thesis or career purposes.

If You Have Already Published in a Predatory Journal

This happens. The question is what to do.

First, check whether your university will accept the publication. Some universities have a blanket policy against predatory journals; others evaluate on a case-by-case basis. Show your Research Cell or PhD coordinator the journal and its verification status. Do not assume the worst until you have confirmed the position.

Second, publish a second paper in a legitimate journal. If the predatory publication will not be accepted, the only solution is to publish a legitimate paper to replace it. Begin this process immediately — do not wait. The Thesis Guide has helped scholars in exactly this situation get a legitimate paper submitted and accepted within a viable timeline.

Third, do not publicise the predatory publication. Do not include it in your CV, your thesis acknowledgements, or any academic application. A predatory publication listed on a CV is a red flag in faculty selection processes.

Fourth, learn from it and move forward. Scholars who published in predatory journals under deadline pressure are not uniquely reckless — they were caught in a system that creates exactly the conditions predatory publishers exploit. The learning is to verify before you submit, start the publication process earlier, and use the five-minute verification process every time.

The Deeper Problem

The predatory journal industry exists because the publication requirement for PhD thesis submission creates desperate, time-pressured scholars who are willing to pay for a publication. The solution is not to eliminate the requirement — it is to start earlier, prepare manuscripts properly, and verify journals before submission.

The Thesis Guide exists precisely for this situation: a working professional with limited time, a publication deadline embedded in their thesis timeline, and the need for a paper that will actually count. Every paper the Thesis Guide writes goes to a journal that has been verified on SCOPUS or UGC CARE — not a third-party site, not a journal’s own claim, but the official portals.

Need Help Getting Published in a Legitimate Journal?

If you are facing a publication deadline and are uncertain whether a journal you are considering is legitimate — or if you need a paper written and submitted to a verified journal on a tight timeline — a free consultation is the right first step.

Request Your Free Consultation →